Friday, May 6, 2016

Light and Dark by Mitchell Shinder


The Metropolitan Museum of Art, located near the heart of Central Park on 81st and fifth avenue, is home to over a million differents texts. These texts are primarily paintings that have originated in various times throughout history. Logistically, the texts are separated into sections based on their origin and message. Some examples of the texts available in the Met are Greco-Roman art, Egyptian art, American art, and Chinese art. I recently visited the museum and explored most of the sections, and one that caught my attention was the American art section.
Upon entering the American art section, a multi-story part of the museum known as the American Wing, one will see some of the most prominent and well-known figures in American history. Figures such as George Washington and Abraham Lincoln are usually depicted on very large vertical paintings within a bright golden/yellow frame that spans nearly an entire wall. I continued walking through the American Wing past these texts, and I soon found myself amidst vivid depictions of several different points throughout American History. These included historical moments such as the Revolutionary War, Civil War, and the Spanish conquests of Native American land.
One room that stood out due to its simplicity was a relatively small room that contained paintings of seas with strong waves (seen in the background of the “dark” image above). At first, I couldn’t understand why a room, albeit small, would be dedicated to pictures of bright backgrounds and rich blue waves. A piece of information that I have been given by the American Wing information desk is that “there is often more than meets the eye”. I quickly realized that hidden in a corner, there was a dark statue of a man whose face was barely visible. The bronze statue, created by Augustus Saint Gaudens, is a monument of Deacon Samuel Chapin. The statue is referred to as “The Puritan”, which indicates that it represents most Puritans in the 16th and 17th century. Some of the key aspects of the text are that the man seems like he is trying to hide himself by wearing a large hat and overcoat/cape. He is also holding a book in his left hand which is unmarked, but I interpreted the book being as being the Bible. In the 16th and 17th centuries, Puritans that separated from the Church of England were often considered extremist, so it is clear why Puritans did not want to be in the spotlight. 
In a room directly adjacent to the one that contained the aforementioned sculpture, there was a shockingly similar use of background and setting to direct one’s focus on a particular text. This room, of similar size to the room with “The Puritan”, contained many paintings of dark forests with miniscule amounts of light passing through the trees. The brightness in the room was instead portrayed through a statue in the middle. In the middle of the room stands a statue made of marble, which has a very “bone-white” color that stands out in an otherwise dark-themed room of forests. This completely contrasts the previous room, and I found this attention to detail particularly interesting. The statue is a semi-nude, topless female referred to as the “Indian Girl”, according to the sculptor. The critical aspects of this sculpture are what the Indian girl is holding in her hands. The statue’s eyes are focused on her right hand that contains a crucifix. The Indian girl is holding feathers in her left hand, which are held below her waist and not the main focus for the girl. Since the girl was Indian, I thought the feathers represented divinity to a creature such as the Quetzal Serpent as discussed in our class based on the Popol Vuh. Therefore, I believe this statue symbolizes evangelization in America in which indigenous people were slowly being converted to Christianity. Overall, the attention to detail by the museum, creators of exhibits, and artists, is truly extraordinary. It is certainly remarkable the difference that a light or dark color, whether through a background or setting, can make in a religious message.
Louis Masi
Professor Steidl
American Religious Texts
6 May 2016
John Street United Methodist Church
            Every Wednesday I head to Wall Street and work for a small, startup digital company. Every time I pass by the John Street United Methodist Church on my commute and I never really thought anything of it, just another old Church in New York City. However, after the class where we discussed the split of Catholicism into the various different denominations, I decided to pay more attention to the Church. It was only then that I realized that this Church, the one I had been ignoring for nearly a month, is actually the oldest continuous Methodist congregation in the country. I had been in the presence of a historic building for a large religious community and had no idea.
            The Church is located at 44 John Street in the Financial District. It clearly stands apart from the rest of the buildings in the area. Sandwiched between corporate office buildings and restaurants, it was hard not to miss but easy to ignore. But what really drew my interest was the shrine that was immediately next to the Church. Besides parks, it is rare to find any grass in New York City, especially in downtown. But this Church had an open gate that allows the general public to walk off the bustling and street and into a quiet place in one of the loudest cities in the world.
            For me, this shrine symbolized the division and integration of religion in metropolitan America today. Although religion used to be the driving force of many cities and towns, that is no longer the case in New York City. Religion has taken a back seat to all the noise of large corporations, sporting events, Broadway, and other attractions. Where religion exists now is in the quiet, away from the loud distractions that the city has to offer. In those quiet, reflective spaces people generally tend to think more about deeper philosophical and religious questions. This gate into the shrine was the physical embodiment of the barrier between society and religion’s place in it today.
            Earlier this semester we discussed if we still saw religion as the cultural center of towns and communities across the United States. The general consensus of the class was that in smaller, rural towns religion held a much more influential hold than in urban areas like New York City. I agree with this wholeheartedly but would also add that in these quiet, religious spaces the influence of religion is no less. The distinction I am trying to make is that the power that religion has over people when exposed to it is no different anywhere else. Although it is not as a big attraction as some other outlets in New York, religion still thrives behind the scenes.
            Religion in the city that never sleeps might be easy to ignore, but that doesn’t mean its presence is not felt. I found it when walking through the John Street United Methodist Church shrine and I know that other New Yorkers can find it too.





Good Friday in the Greek Orthodox Church


Frank Saris
American Religious Texts
Professor Steidl
Blog Post
Sacred Text: Good Friday Procession
Good Friday in the Greek Orthodox Church



Easter is the biggest tradition in Eastern Orthodox Christianity. It is the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. God used his Son to free the bonds of humanity from the devil through the pain of dying on the cross. Greek Orthodox Christians go through a vigorous fast for fifty days and on the last week there is thirty hours of church to celebrate this amazing holiday.
On Good Friday it is purely mournful. People try to refrain from listening to music, watching television, and we follow a strict fast. In church on Good Friday there is a “funeral service”.  The priest and the alter boys take a wooden structure with an icon of Jesus, usually made of cloth, called the Επιτάφιος (epitaphios). This structure symbolizes the burial of Jesus Christ in the stone grave. This wooden structure is then carried outside, either around the church or around the block of the church. In my video it goes around the courtyard of the church. The presentation consists of the priest and the people chanting together in unison, asking God to forgive them for their sin and to help them through their lives. It also thanks God for the sacrifice of his Son. The chants are usually sung in a mournful and grieving tone. The first chant is called the Τρισάγιον or "Thrice Holy". It says “God is Holy”, and is showing the power of God and as a text it is asking him to help us in our endeavors. This chant commemorates how Jesus did not split his humanity and divinity all for the safety of the future generations of Christians. The second chant is asking God to have mercy on us, Κύριε, ἐλέησον (Kýrie eléison). Through Good Friday we show the power of God and thank him for what was done for humanity. We mourn the death of Jesus Christ but are not entirely grief stricten because we know that He is doing this to save us. The after the procession around the courtyard everyone in church walks under the epitafios as a symbol from death to life . After everyone walks under the epitafios, the cloth icon goes around the church and then is place at the alter. Before leaving people go to the epitafios, get a flower and kiss the icon.
As a text we can see that the people are all dressed in suits or dresses. This shows reverence for the House of God and for the funeral presentation. The people sing in a mournful tone with their heads down, praying in their heads, and singing loudly. This brings the community together, people with the same values, having sad emotions together. The candles show light in the darkness, and on Saturday the candles are used for the Resurrection ceremony. The chants can also be read as mournful through the tone and mannerisms of the priest and people. The priest sings and the people chant back, showing a conversation to represent like mindedness. The types of processions, outside then inside, shows the severity of the sacrifice, when the icon passes we do our cross. As American we can see the Greek Orthodox church americanized in their church services. In Greece there are no pews to sit in, people stand for all of church. They also translate some verses for the Americans that do not have a strong Greek tongue.

Pope Francis Mural in Midtown - Jack Brennan

        Although he isn’t there anymore this is what remains of a 180-foot mural of Pope Francis. I had seen the mural in mid-town in October after the Pope had already visited the United States and didn't think anything of it. I never thought to take a picture until I was given this assignment. I went back under the impression that he would still be standing there, smiling and waving at every passerby within a ten block radius. Unfortunately, all that is left is a blank canvas. Its ironic that I would take a picture now of a blank canvas and two men painting over a giant picture of the pope, instead of an amazing mural that I somehow didn’t think anything of in the first place. I remember looking up and seeing the Pope’s face, with www.Popeinusa.com underneath and thinking nothing except that his eyes seemed to be following me. Then I immediately looked back down at the Instagram photos on the two inch by five inch screen in my hand. Now that it is gone though, I regret not taking in the full beauty of the mural. It was a 180 foot painting on the side of an entire building, which must have taken weeks to finish. i probably didn’t even look at it more than five seconds.
Two men painted this beautiful mural in unison. They worked as a team, one mind, and discussed what colors were needed in what areas and what needed more shading. They knew exactly how it looked on paper but somehow were able to see the big picture, while they just painted one brick at a time. It is an amazing work of art that most New Yorkers including myself walked past without a second thought or a moment to reflect on the magnitude of this project just to welcome one man.

Although the mural is a religious symbol, the blank canvas is what inadvertently made me reflect on what I believe to be important in my life. I, for some reason, find that looking at pictures of other peoples faces, food, and pets are all much more important than admiring a beautiful piece of art that can be seen for blocks. The worst part is that I have looked at my phone and all those photos on Instagram at least five times since I have started this blog. I have considered deleting all my social media apps a lot lately. I only wonder if it will help me look around and notice the world a little bit more, or will I just replace it with some other mind-numbing waste of time like Candy Crush. It is weird that it look the lack of a painting of a religious symbol for me to reflect on my own life in a meaningful way.

St. Mark's Church in the Bowery and Social Churches by Pei Jie Gao

            
            This is a picture taken in front of the St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery on March 21st. It is a beautiful church located in the East Village of New York City with rich history. However, it was the banner that says “Black Lives Matter” that really caught my eyes. Churches were usually viewed as a religious institution and as a place to worship. Increasingly, churches took on social issues and became an avenue for social justice as well. The St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery had certainly done so through a quiet but powerful banner.
The St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery is an Episcopal Church, a denomination traditionally associated with the Anglican Church in England. Recently, the Episcopal Church in the United States clashes with their Anglican peers on social issues such as gay rights. Thus, it is not surprising to see that as a member of the Episcopal Church, the St. Mark’s Church in the Bowery would actively engage with social issues. According to the church’s blog on the Huffington Post, the banner was put up last year, after the decision not to indict Daniel Pantaleo, who choke Eric Garner to death in Staten Island. The Church participated in the social movement “Black Live Matters”, and intended to use its populous location to speak out against the “racist system”, according to Rev. Winnie Varghese of St. Mark’s Church. She quoted the Bible “if they keep quiet, the stones will cry out”, and the St. Mark’s Church intends to be the stones that cry out against the injustice for the oppressed.
Throughout this semester, there are examples of religious institutions or individual steps into the public sphere and address a social issue;  Martin Luther King, Jr. and the Civil Rights Movement, Dorothy Day and the Catholic Worker Movement, and the Universalist Unitarian Association and LGBT rights. These successful religious movement all have roots from religious teachings. St. Mark’s Church arguably played a similar role in the Black Live Matters movement. Indeed, the church does not play a prominent role like MLK or the UUA at their respective movements; it did not organize a march on Washington or a rally in Charlotte, but merely puts up a banner. Nonetheless, it is unfair to disqualify or reduce the importance of St. Mark’s Church as an agent of social change because of its relative passive approach to social issues. In my opinion, the success of any social movement depends upon making people aware of the issue, and the Church had done it through the banner; it has caught my attention and perhaps many others that walked by East Village every day. Smaller things may seem insignificant, but it could eventually become a force that drives social change. For example, how many people in the 1950s would have thought that Rosa Parks’ refusal to give up her seat would eventually lead to Civil Rights for African Americans? We cannot know with certainty what the influence of this small step taken by St Mark’s Church will have on the future of the movement, but we should be glad that it has done something to promote a right cause.
On the other hand, there will be a relevant discussion on whether it is the role of the St. Mark’s Church to take on a social issue.  Some might argue while the Church had done a good thing, it acted outside of its boundaries. As we learned earlier in the semester from Robert Bellah, there has always been a conflict between the public and private spheres in the United States. Sometimes it is not welcomed for a religious institution to declare its position on a social issues, especially controversial ones.  The St. Mark Church tackled a relatively “safe” issue and there were not any meaningful backlash, as most people would agree that racism is wrong nowadays. However, making a stance on some “challenging” issues such as LGBT right could incite public outrage, and even criticism from religious peers. As previously mentioned, the Episcopal Church of United States was censured by the Anglican Communion due to its progressive view on LGBT right. Another example can be seen from our class, many students seem to dislike the USCCB’s defense of marriage and denial of LGBT rights, because it did not fit with the classes’ general opinion on the issue and the USCCB was playing the villain role in this case. After all, it seems religious institution needs significant courage to take on the role as a social institution. Thus, I would argue the banner is not a small act, but a significant symbol of bravery of the St. Mark’s Church.
I believe religious institutions will continue to exert its influence on social issues, as it has always done so, despite secular pressure. There are many churches like St. Mark’s Church, and I am sure there will be more churches to shift into a social institution. It is not a bad thing for the society, despite sometimes opinions from different churches might conflict with the general public. After all, religious institutions are part of the society just like any other secular institutions, and their voices should be heard as well. We will debate and argue on many issues, but that is the essence of a democratic society, we cannot ignore the voices of religious institutions simply because we do not like what they are saying (however, exceptions should be made for extremist group like the KKK and ISIS). Religious institutions had been powerful social institutions that drive positive changes in the past, and hopefully new generation of social churches like St. Marks’ Church will continues to do so.


Reference: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rev-winnie-varghese/the-stones-cry-out_b_6271452.html





National 9/11 Memorial By Matthew Modzelewski

            The National 9/11 Memorial is a place of a million meanings. To some, it is a monument to a decisive moment in American history, while to others, it is hallowed ground, similar to that of a cemetery.
Large bronze plaques encircle the reflecting pools that are placed where the World Trade Center buildings once stood, bearing the names of the victims of that tragic act of terror. The plaques have meaningful adjacency. This means that all of the names on the bronze plaques have been placed in such a way that they reflect relationships and friendships of those that died without divulging the connection shared between those placed next to one another. Those that visit the memorial can take a rubbing of the names on the plaques with paper and wax markers distributed by the memorial. This act is meaningful for those that lost someone on that day, but even more meaningful for those that lost someone who remains remain unidentified. The rubbing of their name serves as a way for their family to finally bring them home.
There is no question that the Memorial is “American”, as it represents one of the darkest days in our history by documenting the lives lost on that day. Christians, Jews, and Muslims died on that day together, not as individual members of their respective faiths, but as Americans that were targeted by an extreme force of evil that did not act within the confines of a rational being. Furthermore, the Memorial is the resting place for hundreds of unidentified remains and a place of mourning for those families that were never able to see their loved ones again.
            Despite the special meaning this place holds to many, it is also the source of conflict and hatred. It remembers a time when the nation perceived there was ill intent coming from an entire religion, a religion that is built upon teachings not too dissimilar from those of the Judeo-Christian beliefs. Following the 9/11 attacks, Muslims across the world, especially in the United States were persecuted endlessly due to their religious beliefs. Ignorant individuals, caught up in the tragedy that unfolded, used it as an excuse to release their pent up anger on many individuals very loosely tied to the extremist views of a few individuals. Muslims were denied their basic rights, verbally beaten down, and physically attacked.
            Personally, this site has a particularly positive meaning to me. The meaning transcends the unjust hatred of an entire religious group to reveal that there can be good found in even the worst acts of violence.
Growing up, my mother told me she would never be able to visit the National 9/11 Memorial once it was completed. Unable to grasp why she said this, I played it off as normal emotions, a lifelong New Yorker could not bear the pain involved with seeing a memorial dedicated to the nearly 3,000 lives lost in the matter of minutes. But, once I grew up, I realized it was much deeper than this. My mother knew John J. Badagliacca as a business contact through her position as a portfolio manager at Retirement System Group Inc. His office was located on the 104th floor in Tower 1 of the World Trade Center. Over a span of 14 years, he worked his way up the corporate ladder at Cantor Fitzgerald, earning himself promotion after promotion, eventually getting a position selling bonds for the Treasury. Despite being a busy man dedicated to his work, he always found time in the morning to call my mother to see how she was doing and how her morning was going. Instead of greeting my mother with “Hello Deb” or something of that nature, he would say “Good morning sunshine!” On September 10th, 2001, my mother received a special call from John. The call was not special because of its content, but instead because this would be his last call to my mother. John was one of the 2,753 that perished on September 11th, 2001. His office was located three floors above the location where American Airlines Flight 11 crashed into Tower 1. His name now is memorialized on panel N-52 at the National 9/11 Memorial in Lower Manhattan.

            John J. Badagliacca was a family man that had a profound impact on all those that knew him. John gifted me a red wagon when I was born that I only have fond memories of. Although I never got to meet John, he has taught me a valuable life lesson. I now go through life knowing that it can only take three words to have profound impact on someone’s life.

Christmas Tree at Bryant Park by Chris Laffin


Although seasonal and not even the most famous holiday tree, this landmark captures the winter festival spirit and represents the glow and cheer that come with Christmas and other holidays while in New York. Sitting in the shadow of the Empire State Building and an easy two blocks away from the transit hub of Grand Central Terminal, this destination is one that inspires awe and instills joy in the hearts of tourists and New York natives alike. The bright lights serve as a multi-purpose metaphor; anyone who gazes at it can relate the decoration to the starry night sky or the ever-glowing lights that shine in the city that never sleeps. Although it isn’t technically a religious destination or pertains to a specific Christian denomination, the evergreen is undoubtedly a unique text in the New York landscape. It captures the underlying warmth out in a cold night; the Christian traditions that are sewn into American history are exemplified in the country’s most iconic city during the year’s best holiday. 
The tree overlooks an ice skating rink that is filled with children and adults all doing their best to stay on both feet to avoid the embarrassment of falling while laughter fills the air. This symbol best captures what is great about winter and what is great about New York and it can only be seen during a religious holiday once a year. The tree represents the setting around it- it does not belong to one group or faith but belongs to all who can simply appreciate it. There are temples of every religion within a mile radius of its location, and that speaks volumes to the atmosphere of tolerance and peace it promotes.
The tree is the center of a community free space. Its location and prominent placement is a testament to the grandiose emotions it inspires. Even though the Christmas tree at Rockefeller Plaza is larger or the one at home is decorated with personal ornaments, I truly feel that what makes this one unique is the remarkable belonging it has to it. This tree doesn’t seem like an attraction or a political/religious statement even though one could argue either is true. It just seems to me that its main purpose is to bring joy to people who have seen it either once or a hundred times. It will never be typical or normal. It will always be incredible.

It is because of all these many characteristics that I feel the Christmas Tree at Bryant Park deserves to be included in the conversation about religious texts within the confines of New York City. It has the undeniable glow of its metropolitan home all while conveying the holiday spirit that is most associated with Jesus. Just as one gets lost in one’s own imagination when reading a book, you can truly lose yourself when looking in to its illuminated branches and decorated pines. As a text, it perfectly embodies religion and America.